Winters Insurance Group - Quincy, Illinois

Quincy, IL's Top Insurance Company

Winters Insurance Group began in 1921 under the direction of John McAfee Winters and his two sons, N. McCulloch Winters and Victor Winters. In 1948, the agency moved to its present location, 201 S. 5th St. in Quincy. Today, the agency has 17 employees with a management team consisting of the four principals of the agency, Mike Eaton, Chuck Mahon, Rod Roberts and Jeff Tweedell.

As an Independent Agency, Winters insurance company represents various major insurance companies offering families and businesses the most competitive and comprehensive products available in the marketplace. For all your health insurance, auto insurance, dental insurance & more, call Winters Insurance in Quincy, IL today.

Meet Our Team


Harry C. Eaton, Jr - Partner
Mike Eaton, Partner
Email Mike
Charles R. Mahon - Partner
Chuck Mahon, Partner
Email Chuck
Rodney Roberts - Partner
Rodney Roberts, Partner
Email Rodney
Jeff Tweedell - Partner
Jeff Tweedell, Partner
Email Jeff

Personal Insurance

Carla McKnight - Personal Lines Manager
Carla McKnight, Personal Lines Account Manager
Email Carla
Jennifer Terwelp - Personal Lines Account Manager
Jennifer Terwelp, Personal Lines Account Manager
Email Jennifer
Trent Lepper - Insurance Sales
Trent Lepper, Agent - Personal & Business Lines
Email Trent

Business Insurance

Leslie Coleman - Commercial Lines Account Manager
Leslie Coleman, Commercial Lines Department Manager
Email Leslie
Whitney Buss - Commercial Lines Account Manager
Whitney Buss, Commercial Lines Account Manager
Email Whitney
Toni Stuckman - Commercial Lines Account Manager
Toni Stuckman, Commercial Lines Account Manager
Email Toni
Jen Summers - Commercial Lines Account Manager
Jen Summers, Commercial Lines Account Manager
Email Jen

Life and Health Insurance and Employee Benefits

Lindy Rehrig - Customer Service Professional - Health Insurance
Lindy Rehrig, Customer Service Professional - Health Insurance
Email Lindy
Peggy Johnston
Peggy Johnston, Agent - Life, Health & Employee Benefits
Email Peggy
Brian Dreier - Employee Benefits Director
Brian Dreier,
Employee Benefits Director
Email Brian

Office Management

Trent Lepper - Insurance Sales
Amy McGlaughlin, 
Email Amy
Shelly Shuman - Bookkeeper
Shelly Shuman, 
Email Shelly
Share by: